XDM, fingerprint readers and ecryptfs

I got myself a new toy last week, it’s a ThinkPad X200s. I bought it home for less than 60 euros and for 24 more i got a compatible battery. It’s a nice toy, definitely slow, but I now have something light I can carry around without worrying too much.

Of course, I installed GNU/Linux on it, and to keep things simple I chose Debian with a combination of light applications: XDM as login manager, i3 as window manager, xterm as terminal emulator, GNU Emacs as editor, claws-mail as mail client. The only fat cow on this laptop is Firefox.

As I started saving passwords and stuff on its disk, I decided to encrypt my home folder and my choice for this “simple” setup is ecryptfs. It’s secure enough, simple to setup and integrates very well with other Debian stuff.

This ThinkPad also has a fingerprint reader, correctly recognized by the operating system and I enrolled one of my fingerprints. It’s very comfortable, and it allows me to “sudo su” to root even with people around without fearing shoulder-surfing.

The first login though, it still requires me to input my password as it is needed to unwrap the ecrypts passphrase. And here is where the problem arises: first login is usually done via display manager, namely XDM.

As far as I know XDM, being an old-times thing, has no clue about fingerprint readers and stuff, but the underlying PAM does. And since XDM relies on PAM for authentication… It works, kinda. Basically you either swipe your fingerprint and log in without all your files (you didn’t input your password ⇒ your passphrase was not unwrapped ⇒ your private data was not mounted in your home) or wait for the fingerprint-based login to timeout and XDM to prompt you fro your password.

So if you are okay with waiting 10-15 seconds before being asked for your password then you can stop reading, otherwise keep reading to see how to fix it.

Long story short, PAM in Debian (my guess is that it works pretty much the same for other distributions too) has some nicely formatted, application-specific configuration files under /etc/pam.d . One of those, is /etc/pam.d/xdm and defines how PAM should behave when it’s interacting with XDM.

If you open it, you’ll see it actually does nothing particularly fancy: it just imports some common definition and uses the same settings every application uses that is, try fingerprint first, then fall back on password if it fails or times out.

Such behaviour is defined in /etc/pam.d/common-auth and it is just fine for all other application. For XDM though, it’s advisable in my opinion to ask right out for password and just don’t ask for fingerprint swipe.

My fix for this problem is then to:

  1. open /etc/pam.d/xdm
  2. replace the line importing /etc/pam.d/common-auth with the content of such file
  3. alter the newly added content fo ask right away for the password



Now XDM is going to ask for the password straight away.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.